Modifying the protein to crystallize better

Introduction

There are a number of methods which can be used to modify the crystallization behavior of proteins.

These fall into two classes:

1. Genetic (Mutagenesis) Approach

2. Chemical Modification

1. Genetic/Mutagenesis Approach

This method, also called 'surface entropy-reduction mutagenesis', involves mutation of sidechains on the surface of proteins, in order to reduce the entropic cost of forming ordered intermolecular crystal contacts and thus enhance the crystallizability of proteins.

Typically, large and charged sidechains -- such as lysine and glutamate -- are mutated to small and uncharged sidechains, mostly alanine. The Derewenda laboratory has championed this approach and the state of the art is described in a recent review (Derewenda ZS, and Vekilov PG [2006]. Acta Crystallogr. D62:116–124)

There is a webserver, called SER (Surface Entropy Reduction Prediction Server), which aims to predict sites that are most suitable for mutation designed to enhance crystallizability:

http://nihserver.mbi.ucla.edu/SER/

2. Chemical Modification

Another method for enhancing the crystallizability of proteins involves chemical modification of specific sidechains. Several methods are available:

2.1. Modification of lysine residues

This method, pioneered by the Rayment laboratory, involves the methylation -- under reducing conditions -- of lysine residues. This increases the hydrophobicity of the modified lysine sidechains, reduces the overall solubility of the protein, and -- for some proteins -- promotes the formation of ordered crystal contacts. A recent study (Walter et al. [2006] "Lysine Methylation as a Routine Rescue Strategy for Protein Crystallization" Structure 14:1617–1622) demonstrated that, out of 10 non-crystallizable proteins, 4 proteins became crystallisable after reductive methylation.

2.2. Modification of cyteine residues

This method involves the carboxymethylation -- under reducing conditions -- of single cysteine residues. This effectively neutralizes the cysteine residues (some of which are chemically reactive), increases the overall solubility of the protein and can help prevent aggregation and denaturation problems.

References:

Eiler S et al. (2001) Protein Expr Purif. 22(2):165-73

http://www.ionsource.com/Card/cmc/method.htm -- A protocol for carboxymethylation